Fact-checking the West of England mayoral election

Paul Barltrop
Political editor, West of England@paulbarltrop
West of England Combined Authority Six people stand in a row, four men and two women, with three wearing suits. All six are smiling at the camera.West of England Combined Authority
The six West of England Combined Authority mayoral candidates (left to right): Arron Banks, Steve Smith, Helen Godwin, Mary Page, Oli Henman and Ian Scott

All 700,000 voters in the West of England Combined Authority (Weca) mayoral election have been sent a booklet.

It contains information about voting, and each of the six candidates gets a double-page spread to make their case.

However, some of what they say is inaccurate or misleading.

We've looked at some of the statements that have made their way into the booklets.

The candidates drew lots to determine their order of appearance.

First up is independent Ian Scott, who talks of a "new Frenchay Community Hospital and Urgent Treatment Centre". However, the Weca mayor has no powers over health provision.

Ian Scott Ian Scott's two pages in the campaign booklet feature black and white text, with some headlines in red. The top of the left page says "Speaking truth to power!"Ian Scott
Ian Scott's double page spread in the election booklet, where he writes of a new hospital and treatment centre

Steve Smith, the Conservative candidate, advocates "stopping congestion-creating schemes like the A4 bus lane between Bath and Bristol".

He is referring to a 2023 proposal for a 24-hour bus lane on the Keynsham bypass, but that has already been halted by Weca, and nearly all of the candidates would keep it that way.

Conservative Party A photo of Steve Smith, who is in a blue shirt, next to his pledges including "end the war on the motorist" and "sort out our bus services".Conservative Party
Steve Smith's campaign information refers to plans for a bus lane

Mary Page of the Greens ventures into economic matters, writing: "After 15 years of cuts… instead of us being better off, it's just the multi-millionaires."

But independent experts do not agree.

The Institute for Fiscal Studies says we are all in fact slightly better off than 15 years ago.

Green Party Mary Page's advertising literature, showing her pledges including protecting our environment and growing a thriving economy.Green Party
Mary Page refers to personal finances in her contribution

Next is Arron Banks of Reform, who criticises controversial road changes made by South Gloucestershire Council.

He says he would "demand the re-opening of Thornbury High Street to cars".

But in reality the road is not closed to cars; they can drive along the high street to pick up or drop off.

Reform UK A blue page, showing a photo of Arron Banks, in a black suit, and a list of his pledges, including demanding the re-opening of Thornbury High Street to cars.Reform UK
Arron Bank's pledges mention Thornbury High Street, which is already open to cars

Like many candidates, Helen Godwin of Labour wants more trains.

She says she will "secure new railway stations including Ashton Gate, St Anne's, Brabazon, Portishead, Saltford and Charfield".

But no securing is needed for two of those; work is already under way for Brabazon and Charfield.

By contrast, two others, St Anne's and Saltford, are long-term ideas with no agreed plan or funding, which will not come in the next four years.

Labour Party Helen Godwin's booklet text, showing four photos of Helen alongside various pledges including securing new railway stations and building new homes.Labour Party
Work is already under way for some of the stations listed in Helen Godwin's plan

The last to make his pledges is Liberal Democrat Oli Henman; he talks of "developing a mass rapid transit system".

He means trams or a metro, as previously proposed in Bristol, and in his campaign he says he would deliver it.

But costs would be huge, so that would also not happen in the next four-year mayoral term.

Liberal Democrats Oli Henman's booklet text, listing his pledges including better transport, better housing, better environment and more. There are two photos of him on the page.Liberal Democrats
Oli Henman's pledge for a metro would not be achievable in a four-year term

Other information in the booklet is more certain.

Postal voting to choose the next West of England mayor is under way.

Polling day is 1 May, and voters are reminded that they need to bring a valid photo ID.

The count, and the result, will come overnight.