Casement Park would be 'dealt with by now' if it was football

GAA An artist's impression of the proposed new stadium, which would have a capacity of 34,500GAA
An artist's impression of the proposed new stadium, which would have a capacity of 34,500

The Gaelic Athletic Association (GAA) told Stormont's sports minister that issues with Casement Park would have been "dealt with by now" had they occurred in football or rugby.

The remarks emerged in minutes of a "fraught and tetchy" meeting between Gordon Lyons and the GAA about the stalled stadium plans, which have been seen by the BBC.

GAA president Jarlath Burns also challenged the Democratic Unionist Party (DUP) minister over why he had not attended any matches since taking up office.

Lyons said he "does not accept engagements on Sundays" - and that Casement has been "treated in the same manner" as other projects.

'Candid conversations'

The minister said Stormont's previous funding pledge "still stands", but there were "budget constraints" affecting his department.

The meeting with senior GAA officials was held at the end of October.

It followed the halting of plans to build the stadium in time for the Euro 2028 football tournament, after the UK government said it would not contribute any funding.

A source last year said the meeting was at times "fraught and tetchy" and Mr Burns had accused Lyons of "dragging his heels".

Minutes obtained by BBC News NI through a Freedom of Information request were significantly redacted.

The Department for Communities (DfC) argued releasing the full documents would disclose "commercially sensitive information".

According to the minutes, Mr Burns told the minister he wanted "good relations" with the department and "candid conversations in friendship".

"He also referenced that the minister had not attended a GAA match and stressed that the invitation remains open," according to the records.

Lyons noted he had attended a GAA event the previous month and was "willing" to attend a GAA match, "but does not accept engagements on Sundays".

David Young/PA GAA president Jarlath Burns with colleagues after meeting Communities Minister Gordon Lyons in OctoberDavid Young/PA
GAA president Jarlath Burns, centre, with colleagues after meeting Communities Minister Gordon Lyons in October

'Sporting codes'

Plans for Casement Park were developed as part of a Stormont executive funding programme agreed in 2011, which also delivered upgrades to Ravenhill rugby stadium and the football ground at Windsor Park.

Stephen McGeehan, Ulster GAA's head of operations, said the "GAA's position is that the 2011 executive commitment was to meet the strategic needs of the sporting codes".

"GAA believe that equivalent problems in other sporting codes would have been dealt with by now," the minutes added.

Lyons said that Casement Park was "treated in the same manner as the two other stadia".

He acknowledged the GAA's "frustration", but he said the Stormont executive's 2011 funding commitment "still stands".

The minister noted that "due to budget constraints, it was not possible to progress other executive capital projects, for example social housing".

But he "recognised the strategic need for sport".

Liam McBurney/PA Communities Minister Gordon LyonsLiam McBurney/PA
Communities Minister Gordon Lyons said Stormont's previous funding commitment "still stands"

How much will Casement cost?

It was agreed, according to the minutes, that the minister would seek a meeting with the Northern Ireland Secretary, Hilary Benn, "to discuss the funding at a ministerial level".

In the Stormont assembly on Tuesday, Lyons said he had written to the secretary of state "to ask for an update on the government's view of the project".

The Northern Ireland Executive originally pledged £62.5m towards Casement Park, with the GAA providing £15m.

But the plans have suffered years of setbacks and the projected cost has risen significantly beyond the initial estimate of £77.5m.

In September, the UK government said the estimated build costs had "risen dramatically" to "potentially over £400m".

Ulster GAA secretary Brian McAvoy said this cost was "wildly exaggerated".

The organisation has sought to slightly modify the stadium design after plans to host some Euro 2028 matches were dropped.

In November, the GAA said a reported estimate of around £270m was "closer" to the assumptions it was working on.

The Department for Communities (DfC) and the GAA have been approached for comment.